8List.ph is published by ID8, Inc.

‘Percy Jackson’ vs. ‘Harry Potter’: The Internet is Divided Over Which TV Series to Be Excited About

You’ve probably heard that YA favorite Percy Jackson is set to have a TV adaptation. After years of shouting into the ether (in our case, the internet) that the five-book series deserves to have its own movie franchise, it looks like fans are being heard. Coincidentally, while the internet is rejoicing over the new Percy Jackson development, Harry Potter, yet another well-loved series, is rumored to have a live-action series too. The internet, of course, has its own opinions.

Percy Jackson is progressing


Series author Rick Riordan shared that “everyone who has read the pilot script [for Percy Jackson] loved it.” Although he acknowledges that the journey to take Percy to the small screen will take some time since top execs at Disney+ need to review everything. “All the input has been super positive and helpful, though. Everyone is committed to making this the best show we possibly can,” he wrote on his website.

Riordan first announced the live-action TV adaptation with Disney+ last May and in December, he shared a short clip of the logo. Fans are relieved he was included in the creation since the first two Percy Jackson live-action movies didn’t do so well.


Enter live-action TV contender: Harry Potter


The Percy development wasn’t the only news that shook the fandom world, apparently, HBO Max is rumored to be planning a Harry Potter live-action TV adaptation. However, before the world could digest the news, Warner Bros. and HBO Max shot down the rumors. “There are no Harry Potter series in development at the studio or on the streaming platform,” they told Variety. But if there would be a TV series in the future, people are not having it.

The fandoms clash


After eight films and a truckload of spin-offs later, people are tired of Harry Potter and his adventures. The wizarding world is cool and all but it’s time for Percy’s world of mythology to take center stage. Everyone was disappointed with the first two movie adaptations of the first two books Percy Jackson and the Lightning Thief (2010) and Percy Jackson: Sea of Monsters (2013) and are eager to be handed fresh material that stays true to literature.

Which is better


Who is the better protagonist? Demigod Percy Jackson or The Boy Who Lived himself, Harry Potter? Which friends-slash-sidekicks reign supreme — Annabeth Chase and Grover or Ron Weasley and Hermione Granger? Honestly, these books are both great on their own and do not deserve to be pitted against each other. Percy probably taught you all your knowledge about Greek mythology (to the point where you can’t distinguish fiction from actual mythology) and everyone enjoyed getting lost in Harry Potter‘s complex world-building. At the end of the day, they’re both fiction.


And then there’s the matter of JK Rowling


Obviously, series creator JK Rowling would profit from yet another Harry Potter adaptation, dismaying everyone. Rowling has frequently made headlines for her controversial views on transgender people. This controversy could be the exact reason why executives won’t push through with a series in the first place.


We’re caught in the middle


Streaming giants are shoving franchises, spin-offs, and new series down our throats but we’re here for it anyway. So a PJ and HP series in the works could only mean one thing: we’re winning. (Or they are, if you consider the subscription fees… yikes).

We believe in Logan Lerman comeback


The first two Percy Jackson movies were a waste of Logan Lerman’s acting prowess, handsomeness, and charm. He was Percy Jackson in the flesh, utterly perfect for the role, and yet cast in a flop movie. Don’t even get us started on Alexandra Daddario’s Annabeth Chase! Fans have been clamoring for both actors to be cast as Poseidon and Athena, their Greek god parents. It’s highly unlikely but a girl can dream.

It’s Percy time, Potter


In conclusion, we love Harry Potter and the series has got a special place in our hearts. But it’s time to pass Percy Jackson the torch. We’re ready for an era of demigods taking up the small screen!

Which live-action TV adaptation would you watch first?


Total
74
Shares
73
0
1

Kyzia spends most of her time capturing the world around her through photos, paragraphs, and playlists. She is constantly on the hunt for the perfect chocolate chip cookie, and a great paperback thriller to pair with it.


You May Also Like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Your daily dose of entertaining, useful and informative lists.